8 Holistic Assessment Examples & How to Implement Them

8 Holistic Assessment Examples & How to Implement Them

Holistic assessment has always been a key aspect of effective training and development. The benefits of holistic assessment are numerous, so implementing the practice in your business is a worthwhile project.

That said, how do you implement holistic training in an organisation? To help answer this question, we’ll first look at examples of holistic assessment and then discuss the need-to-know basics of implementation.

Holistic Assessment Examples

The following are modern examples of holistic assessment as used in the real world. This list can be implemented in a variety of industries.

1. Project-Based Assessments

This powerful method tests real-world skills against predetermined competency standards. As a form of skill-based learning, this method requires learners to complete a project testing their skills and competencies in a true-to-life scenario.

The main advantage here is clear. If employees can handle a real-world project, you have sound evidence of their competency. However, this does require a competent professional or subject-matter expert to oversee the assessment and ensure that the outcome is accurately judged.

Most businesses already use this method. For example, interns or apprentices who are learning their roles utilise this method.

2. Portfolios

Portfolios enable effective holistic assessment in the form of past work done. A good portfolio often contains:

  • Images of projects.
  • Objectives.
  • Outcomes.
  • Challenges faced and how they were overcome.
  • Any other relevant information.

Portfolios largely eliminate the need for manual assessment, given that evidence of skills already exists within. This method is especially useful during recruitment or when assigning a team to a new project.

One example is a project manager’s list of completed projects, compiled into a single document. This portfolio will also highlight the relevant deadlines and dates of completion, illustrating the project manager’s ability to keep large initiatives running smoothly.

While portfolios can reduce the need for manual assessment, they do not completely eliminate it. The quality and relevance of the portfolio content to specific roles or projects need thorough evaluation.

3. Self-Assessment And Peer Review

This is an example of ongoing holistic assessment within a working environment. It encourages individuals to reflect on their own performance, but also to provide sincere feedback to colleagues.

For example, when a team has completed a project, each member rates their perceived contribution and that of their colleagues. They can also highlight strengths or areas of improvement within the team. This allows teams to take accountability for their performance and make operational excellence the cornerstone of all they do.

The success of these assessments depends on the culture of openness and honesty in the organisation. Without it, feedback may be less effective.

4. Competency-Based Assessments

Supervisor conducts performance assessment as a holistic assessment exampleCompetency-based assessments aim to measure the cumulative practical skills of employees before they’re placed in real-world scenarios.

A common usage of this method is the trade test. Before an apprentice is allowed to work as a qualified tradesman, they must prove their knowledge and skill with a competency-based assessment.

These assessments are typically structured and standardised to ensure fairness and consistency across candidates.

5. Performance-Based Assessments

This form of assessment aims to test competency in a real-world scenario on an ongoing basis. This can be on the job or in a simulated scenario. For example, a sales team may hold a staged pitch session or a fire response team might run a drill.

When observed by a competent assessor, this method can help maintain an accurate overview of performance during on-the-job training. This helps employers to serve the right training at the right time.

The effectiveness of this method relies on the realism of the scenario and the competency of the assessor.

6. 360-Degree Feedback

This comprehensive means of holistic assessment involves gathering feedback from supervisors, peers and direct reports. This gives an accurate reflection from all angles on an individual’s strengths and areas of improvement.

You can apply this example to almost any situation, and it’s a great tool to direct focus on improving operational excellence every day. The implementation of 360-degree feedback requires a well-structured process and often a supportive assessment platform to manage the feedback effectively.

7. Case Studies and Scenario Analysis

This method places learners into difficult situations that occurred in the past. Hypothetical scenarios are another way to use this method. Learners get to apply their knowledge to complex situations and develop critical thinking, problem-solving, and decision-making skills.

This method is most often used in law and medicine-type industries, but can also be useful for industrial teams, such as safety departments. The challenge lies in selecting or designing cases and scenarios that are both relevant and challenging for the learners.

8. Simulations

Here learners can apply their skills in a highly realistic, controlled environment. This helps to mitigate the risks of certain real-life scenarios, such as working with explosives, flying a plane, or performing an operation.

Common industries in which we see this method utilised are the military, medicine, and aviation. Simulations are also an example of on-the-job training that can be used for assessment purposes.

The main limitation is the cost and complexity of developing and maintaining high-fidelity simulations.

Implementing Holistic Assessment Examples

Successful holistic assessment example celebrated by workersEach type of holistic assessment method has its own unique implementation best practices. However, there are key steps that are universal and with a little tweaking, you can apply them to most methods.

1. Define Competency Requirements

The obvious starting point is to define, in detail, what competency looks like for each type of assessment. This could be according to a pre-existing KPI, defined assessment scores, or the successful completion of projects.

The key to this step is clear guidelines on what equals competency. For example, what does the successful completion of a project look like? For example, the close of a sale, the successful repair of a machine, or the correct installation of a new piece of equipment.

Ensure that employees have a clear understanding of requirements and that assessors know what to look for. There must be no room for ambiguity. A great tool to assist in this exercise is your existing competency matrix.

Don’t have a competency matrix yet? Download Our free Competencies Matrix template now!

2. Clear Action Plans

Whatever the outcome of the assessment, clear next steps are a great addition. In a failed assessment, stipulate further training. If the learner is successful, provide a list of more advanced holistic training exercises that the learner may choose to action next.

This step helps to remove ambiguity and gives both the assessor and learner a clear path of progression.

3. Participant Guidelines

It’s always a good idea to include clear guidelines on conduct. For example, can the assessor assist during a performance-based assessment? What are the criteria for an assessor to get involved? (Eg. Unsafe work practice.)

Make it clear to avoid any disputes or complications on the matter.

Using 360-degree feedback, how is anonymity ensured? Are there guidelines on delivering feedback (constructive instead of offensive)? List these out clearly to ensure that all participants are aware of and can adhere to core guidelines.

4. Recordkeeping for Proof of Competency

One important aspect of implementing holistic assessment is effective recordkeeping. Storing proof of training and competency is vital – and paper storage systems aren’t reliable enough to fulfil this requirement in modern times.

Not only are paper processes unreliable in terms of data security, but they also damage efficiency, as we’ll explore in the next section.

Always look for reliable ways to store your training information. This can range from manually scanning proof and then storing it safely on the cloud, to using a specialised training and assessment system to aid your efforts (and reduce admin).

Challenges When Implementing Holistic Assessment

As with any newly introduced process, there are certain challenges when implementing a holistic assessment example of any kind.

  • Data Loss: Risk of losing critical assessment data due to technological failures or mishandling, which can compromise the evaluation of learning and progress.
  • Time Loss: Implementing holistic assessments often requires significant time for planning, execution, and evaluation, potentially detracting from work or other educational activities.
  • Ensuring Consistency and Reliability in Assessments: Achieving uniform standards across different assessors and ensuring that evaluations are consistent and reliable over time can be challenging, particularly with subjective assessment methods.
  • Training Educators: Trainers need comprehensive training to design and administer holistic assessments effectively, requiring investment in professional development and support structures.
  • Addressing Potential Bias in Subjective Evaluations: Subjective assessments, such as peer reviews or reflective journals, may introduce personal biases into the evaluation process, affecting fairness and accuracy.

Given the challenges we face, what potential solutions exist to mitigate these factors? The simple answer lies in cloud-based technology.

Cloud-Based Holistic Assessment Tools

CEO integrates cloud-based holistic assessment softwareWhile you can implement holistic assessment in your company by yourself, it’s wise to consider a cloud-based system. These digital solutions provide a wide range of assessment tools and can handle all the admin.

To help lighten the load of implementation, consider Cloud Assess. It’s a cloud-based assessment software that offers many valuable functions. Such as:

  • Custom assessment documents
  • Tracking and reporting
  • Offline functionality and mobile friendliness
  • Calendar and in-app messaging
  • Privacy and security
  • Too many more to list here.

The number of assessment software solutions is always growing, so there’s no need to stick to outdated systems or processes.

The Value Of Holistic Assessments

Holistic assessments can offer a real-time view of skill coverage, employee performance, development over time, and more. As the business landscape continues to be hyper-competitive, we cannot afford to hold on to any siloed, inefficient methods of assessment.

If you’re interested in learning more about holistic assessment, sharpen your understanding of the benefits of holistic assessment here.

Deliver Your Skills Training Without Compromise

2000 1000 Gianpiero Rusconi